← Back to CSDDD Insights
CSDDD guidelines: US government comments on territorial reach, fines, verification and civil liability

What the US Asked the EU to Change in the CSDDD Guidelines, and What It Means for Non-EU Companies

What the US Asked the EU to Change in the CSDDD Guidelines, and What It Means for Non-EU Companies

The Commission's CSDDD implementation guidelines are due in Q1 2027. They will not rewrite the directive, but they will shape how supervisors and courts read it. That is why a detailed submission from the US government during the consultation is worth reading closely if you are a non-EU company with EU turnover.

The timeline

The Commission's consultation on the guidelines closed on 14 August 2026, and it plans to adopt them in Q1 2027. The US government filed detailed comments in August 2026, following commitments in the 2025 US-EU trade framework under which the EU agreed to address US concerns about CSDDD and CSRD. One legal commentator argues the later reforms did not fully address those concerns [1].

What the US asked for

According to a summary published by EAPIL on 29 September 2026, the submission makes these main requests [1]:

  • Narrower scope. Limit CSDDD to EU subsidiaries of US companies and EU business partners, and limit due diligence to goods produced in, or services supplied from, the EU.
  • Equivalence. Treat countries with robust regulation as low-risk and create a "presumed compliance" route for companies under equivalent regimes.
  • EU-entity responsibility. Place due diligence and enforcement on EU entities rather than third-country parent companies.
  • Fines on EU revenue. Base penalties on EU revenue, not worldwide turnover.
  • Risk-based audits. Use audits and site visits only on a risk basis, and subject third-party verifiers to independence, accreditation and sectoral expertise requirements.
  • Civil liability. Allow claims under Article 29 only after a supervisory authority finds non-compliance, require claimants to show direct links to harm in or materially affecting the EU, and avoid new procedural routes for CSDDD claims.
  • Climate. Welcome the deletion of the climate transition plan provision, and ask that equivalent duties not be recreated through guidance or national transposition, including via OECD standards.
info Note

This is a summary of a government submission, written by a commentator. It reflects the US position, not Commission policy or a prediction of the final guidelines.

Which asks look hard to deliver

Guidelines are non-binding interpretation of a directive that is already in the Official Journal. Several requests would need changes to the legal text: shifting the scope to EU entities only, switching the fine basis from worldwide to EU revenue, or conditioning civil claims on a prior supervisory finding. The commentary notes the submission raises questions about territorial reach, regulatory overlap, public enforcement and private enforcement [1]. Expect the guidelines to address the softer asks first, such as verification standards and risk-based prioritisation, where interpretation has room to move.

What this means for a non-EU company

First, do not plan around a scope carve-out that has not been granted. If your EU turnover puts you in scope, the directive's obligations are what apply today. Our non-EU scope guide covers the threshold test.

Second, the verification asks are the most actionable. If the Commission sets accreditation and independence expectations for third-party verifiers, your audit programme will be judged against them. Revisit which schemes and auditors you rely on, as discussed in our piece on industry schemes and audits.

Third, build the evidence trail now. Whether the guidelines favour risk-based or broader audits, a documented risk map and prioritisation rationale will serve you either way.

1
Confirm scope

Check your EU turnover against the directive's thresholds and identify the EU entity that would carry obligations.

2
Track the guidelines

Calendar the Q1 2027 adoption and review the final text for verifier, equivalence and prioritisation language.

3
Stress-test your audits

Check whether your third-party verifiers and schemes could meet independence, accreditation and expertise expectations.

4
Document risk-based choices

Record why you prioritised the suppliers and sites you did, so the decision is defensible under any final guidance.

help_outlineAre the CSDDD guidelines binding?expand_more

No. They are interpretive guidance for companies and Member State authorities, but they will heavily influence supervision.

help_outlineDid the US submission change the directive?expand_more

No. It is a consultation response. Any change to scope, fines or liability would need legislative action or national transposition choices.

help_outlineWhen will the guidelines be adopted?expand_more

The Commission plans to adopt them in Q1 2027.

help_outlineShould non-EU companies pause preparation?expand_more

No. Scope and obligations remain as set in the directive until changed, and evidence-building pays off under any outcome.

Source: U.S. Government Comments on the Forthcoming CSDDD Guidelines, EAPIL [1].