← Back to CSDDD Insights
CBAM fertilisers: Article 27a safety valve, Council vs Parliament, tariff suspension and certificate exposure

CBAM on Fertilisers After Parliament Deleted the Safety Valve: What Importers Still Owe

CBAM on Fertilisers After Parliament Deleted the Safety Valve: What Importers Still Owe

Fertilisers are the most politically charged corner of CBAM. Prices spiked, farm lobbies pushed for relief, and the Commission floated an emergency brake. Then Parliament deleted it. Here is where things stand and what fertiliser importers should assume.

Why fertilisers became the pressure point

In January 2026, France and Italy pushed for farmer protection, arguing the carbon levy combined with fertiliser prices about 60% above 2020 levels threatened farm incomes [1]. By April, nitrogen fertiliser cost EU farmers about 71% more than the 2024 average, according to one agricultural outlet, which attributes the spike to the closure of the Strait of Hormuz [2]. The Commission adopted its Fertiliser Action Plan on 19 May 2026. Farm group Copa-Cogeca asked for CBAM on fertilisers to be suspended; the Commission has not offered that [2].

What relief was actually delivered

Two things happened on the tariff and rules side. On 24 February 2026 the Commission announced it would temporarily suspend most favoured nation duties on urea and ammonia imports for one year, for all countries except Russia and Belarus [3]. And the Commission adopted an exception to the standard CBAM calculation rules for fertilisers, which the Action Plan consolidates [2]. Neither removes the certificate obligation.

The safety valve: proposed, then deleted

The Commission proposed Article 27a, which would let it temporarily remove goods from CBAM scope in serious and unforeseen circumstances such as a price spike. Exclusions could apply retroactively to 1 January 2026, and certificates bought during a suspension would be reimbursed [1].

On 15 September 2026, Parliament confirmed by 464 votes to 50, with 159 abstentions, the deletion of Article 27a. Its environment committee had made the deletion in July. Parliament's substitute keeps certificate obligations running during a shock and directs CBAM revenue to affected sectors through the Temporary Decarbonisation Fund, with Parliament's fund position running 2027 to 2029 and open to downstream operators including fertiliser producers and users [4].

The Council went the other way. Its 12 June 2026 general approach kept the exemption with tighter conditions: objective criteria, a minimum of one full calendar year, a maximum of two years, and a pause in the reduction of EU ETS free allocation for EU installations producing exempted goods [4].

PointCommissionCouncil (12 June 2026)Parliament (15 Sept 2026)
Article 27a safety valveProposedKept, with tighter conditionsDeleted
Certificates during a price shockReimbursed if suspendedExemption of 1 to 2 years possibleStill owed
Support mechanismNone specificPause in free allocation reduction for EU producersTemporary Decarbonisation Fund, 2027 to 2029

What remains unresolved

The two positions differ, so the trilogues must settle it. One commentator notes trilogues often produce conditional versions of contested clauses rather than clean deletions, and that they will also cover the product list (about 200 downstream products in the Council text versus about 457 in Parliament's), scrap treatment and the fund's start date [4]. Do not bank on either outcome.

What importers still owe

Using the same commentary's example, urea from Egypt (CN 3102 10 19) at the Q3 2026 certificate price of EUR 82.32 per tonne CO2e carries about EUR 43.17 per tonne, while an origin without its own default value carries about EUR 153.75. Fertilisers also enjoy a lower 1% default mark-up, against 10% to 30% for other sectors [4]. These are one source's illustrative figures; recompute with your own CN codes and verified data.

star Important

Plan on certificate obligations continuing through any future price shock. Treat any later relief as upside, and note that fund support under Parliament's position would arrive after the fact.

1
Compute exposure by origin

Run your fertiliser CN codes against actual and default values for each origin, since the gap between origins can be several times larger than the base cost.

2
Prioritise supplier data

Ask producers for verified installation data so you can move off defaults where it lowers the cost.

3
Budget certificates

Include certificate cost in your 2027 purchasing model from the February 2027 start of sales.

4
Watch the trilogues

Track the Article 27a outcome and the Temporary Decarbonisation Fund start date as separate scenarios.

help_outlineAre fertilisers exempt from CBAM?expand_more

No. They are not permanently exempt, and no suspension has been adopted.

help_outlineDoes the urea and ammonia tariff suspension remove CBAM costs?expand_more

No. It suspends MFN customs duties for one year. CBAM certificate obligations are separate.

help_outlineIs Article 27a dead?expand_more

Not yet. Parliament deleted it but the Council kept a tighter version, so it is a trilogue issue.

help_outlineIs the lower default mark-up certain to last?expand_more

The 1% figure comes from one commentary on current rules. Check the current implementing acts before budgeting.

Sources: ClearBlue Markets [1]; Wikifarmer [2]; BC Insight [3]; cbamguide.com [4].